It wasn't too long into the film when I realized that the strange feeling washing over me was boredom. How could that be?, I thought. I've been waiting for this movie ever since I read Alan Moore and Dave Gibbons' groundbreaking graphic novel in 2003, finally realizing what the hell brought on the grim 'n' gritty glut of comic book storytelling that was the 90's.
Certainly the opening sequence couldn't be the culprit; it looked like the comic book pages depicting The Comedian's murder come to life. Nor could it have been the breathtaking opening credits, which did a tidy job of exposition while adding new bits not seen in the book (the JFK assassination, anyone?). Jackie Earle Haley couldn't embody Rorschach more if he tried; ditto Billy Crudup as Dr. Manhattan. And don't get me started on the hot hunk of dude that is Jeffrey Dean Morgan. Special effects? Check. Kick-ass action sequences? Check. Faithfulness to the source material? Double check.
And then it hit me. When a prose novel is adapted into a film, we are treated to a visual interpretation of the words that previously only existed in our imaginations. When a comic book is adapted into a film, there's usually hundreds and hundreds of issues of source material to choose from, so part of the fun comes in finding out which bits of the characters' canons make it to the screen. Watchmen is a mere twelve issues. Wisely, director Zach Snyder chose to adhere as closely to those issues as possible, ending up with what is most likely the most faithful page-to-screen adaptation of a comic book we've ever seen.
Hence the boredom.
It's hard to elicit thrills from an audience that is already intensely familiar with what is essentially the storyboards for your film. They've already seen the work represented visually, and by a storytelling expert, no less, so any element of surprise is gone. "Ah, yes. Now they're going to Mars. Yep, now they're going to confront Adrian." Not only do we know what's going to happen, but we also know just what it will look like. A movie version is practically redundant.

Snyder didn't really have a choice; if he had strayed from the book any more than he did, the streets would be running red with his blood right now. But part of me wishes he had employed a little more of the daring seen in the opening credits. Certain subplots eliminated or compressed. Characters amalgamated. New information extrapolated from things we already know. Taking the existing work as a reference and creating something new. Things that can usually found in true adaptations.
Ultimately, Watchmen's appeasement of its fans is what will keep it from ever truly being a fan favorite. Or maybe it's just that Malin Ackerman.


and we still have no idea what his power is! He's very mysterious; the Wolverine of his time. My guess is that he has tactile telekinesis, or maybe supersonic budget balancing, or hey! Maybe he has a utility belt full of economic stimulii, Iraqi treaties, and photon-fueled shark pellets.









